Skip to content

Shopify vs. Own Website: Renting or Owning Your Online Shop

Updated on:
Updated by: Ciaran Connolly

The Shopify vs. own website decision is a choice between renting a hosted shop and owning one you control. Shopify suits new sellers who need to launch quickly and want hosting handled for them. A self-hosted site, usually WordPress with WooCommerce, suits established shops that want full control of their data, design, and search visibility. ProfileTree builds on both.

What “Your Own Website” Means When Shopify Is Also a Website

A 3D graphic labelled Rent or Own? showing a commercial building next to a residential house with a key in the door, representing the choice between Shopify vs own website.

Shopify is a website, so the real question is who controls the platform beneath it. On Shopify, you pay a monthly subscription for software, hosting and a checkout that Shopify runs and updates for you. On a self-hosted site, you pay for hosting (the server space that stores and delivers your pages) and run open-source software such as WordPress, with the WooCommerce plugin adding the shop.

A useful comparison is a fitted unit in a managed shopping centre against a shop you own outright. The centre looks after security, power and the tills, and you can open within days, but you follow its rules and pay its charges for as long as you trade there. Owning the building costs more at the start and puts the upkeep on you, while every decision about the layout, the till and the lease stays with you.

Neither arrangement is right for every business. The mistake we see most often is a shop staying in the rented model after it has outgrown it, or taking on ownership before anyone is ready to look after it. If the owned route appeals, our WordPress web design page explains how ProfileTree plans and builds sites that owners can run themselves after launch.

Where Shopify Hosts Your Store

Shopify is a hosted platform, so you cannot move its software onto a server of your own. For merchants in the UK and the European Economic Area, Shopify’s published list of subprocessors says customer personal data is first processed by Shopify International Limited in Ireland, with Google Cloud Canada hosting the platform data. A self-hosted site sits wherever you choose to host it, and that can be a UK data centre.

Shopify vs Own Website at a Glance

The table sets out where the two models differ most. Each row is covered in more detail in the sections that follow.

FactorShopifySelf-hosted (WordPress with WooCommerce)
Time to launchDays for a simple theme storeUsually several weeks for a professional build
Upfront costLow, with the Basic plan at £25 a month on monthly billingHigher, with a new ProfileTree website from £4,000 plus VAT
Platform surcharge on salesNone with Shopify Payments; 2% on Basic with a third-party gatewayNone
Card processing2% plus 25p per online UK card payment on Basic with Shopify PaymentsSet by your gateway, for example 1.5% plus 20p for standard UK cards on Stripe
Extra featuresMostly monthly app subscriptionsMostly plugins, many with annual licences
Design controlStrong for standard layouts, with checkout changes limited below PlusFull control, checkout included
Search controlGood basics, with part of the URL structure fixedFull control of URLs, templates and content
Technical upkeepShopify handles hosting, security, and platform updatesYou or your developer handle updates, security and backups
LeavingPossible, with data export and redirect workCopy the files and database to another host

Speed to Market and the Work You Take On

A rocket launching from an open laptop next to a toolbox and shield icon, illustrating the trade-off between launch speed and upkeep when choosing between Shopify vs an own website.

Shopify’s clearest advantage is time. A seller without any technical background can pick a theme, add products, connect Shopify Payments and take orders within days, because the checkout, the hosting and the SSL certificate (the security layer behind the padlock in the browser) are already in place. For anyone testing a product or selling online for the first time, that removes a real barrier.

Building your own shop involves more parts. A professional WordPress build needs a hosting environment, a design, WooCommerce configured for your products, tested plugins, and payment and delivery integrations, and it usually takes several weeks from brief to launch. That suits a business with time and budget in hand, and it is a problem when orders need to be coming in before the end of the month.

The upkeep follows the ownership. On Shopify, server maintenance and PCI compliance (the card industry’s security standard) belong to Shopify. On an owned site, software updates, security monitoring and backups fall to you, which in practice means a maintenance plan such as ProfileTree’s managed hosting and maintenance service, or a member of staff who knows WordPress well.

Design Control and the Checkout

Both platforms can produce a professional shop, and the differences show at the edges. Shopify’s themes are well built and suit a standard catalogue, and plenty of stores never need more. The friction starts when a shop needs something the theme and the app store do not offer, such as unusual product configuration, trade pricing for wholesale buyers, or a checkout that collects extra information.

The checkout is Shopify’s main constraint. Deeper checkout changes are largely reserved for Shopify Plus, which Shopify prices in US dollars from $2,300 a month on a three-year term. For a shop whose buying process is part of what it sells, made-to-order products or subscription boxes, for example, that ceiling can decide the platform on its own.

WooCommerce has no equivalent limit, because the code runs on your server and can be changed. The cost of that freedom is that every custom feature has to be built, tested, and maintained by someone. If you are weighing the two shop platforms feature by feature, our Shopify and WooCommerce decision guide goes through them in detail.

Search Visibility and Content on Each Model

Search is where the platform choice has its longest-lasting effect. Shopify handles the basics well: it generates a sitemap (a file listing your pages for search engines), lets you edit page titles and descriptions, and adds canonical tags (which tell Google the main version of a page) to products reached through collection pages.

The limits are structural. Shopify fixes parts of the URL pattern, so products sit under /products/ and categories under /collections/, and you cannot remove those folders. Its blog works, but it was added to a shop, and businesses that depend on guides and articles to win customers often find it restrictive.

WordPress began as a publishing platform. It lets you decide your URLs, templates, schema (structured data that describes a page to search engines and AI assistants), and the way articles link to products. For an SME that wants organic search to bring in customers without depending on advertising, that control compounds over two or three years. Our WordPress and Shopify cost and SEO comparison covers the technical differences further.

What Running a Shop Really Costs

The monthly subscription is the smallest part of what an online shop costs on either model. The fees that rise as you sell more are card processing and, on Shopify, the platform surcharge, and both are often described inaccurately in comparisons.

What Shopify Charges UK Merchants

Shopify’s Basic plan costs £25 billed monthly, or £19 a month when paid yearly, according to Shopify’s UK pricing page. With Shopify Payments, you pay a card rate of 2% plus 25p on each online UK card payment, and no separate platform fee. If a third-party gateway (a payment provider outside Shopify, such as PayPal or Worldpay) is your main way of taking payment, Shopify adds its own surcharge of 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow and 0.6% on Advanced, on top of what the gateway charges.

That surcharge is the fee that does the most damage. A shop taking £200,000 a year through PayPal or Worldpay on Basic pays Shopify £4,000 a year before the gateway takes its own share. Switching to Shopify Payments removes the surcharge, although you then accept Shopify’s card rates and payout terms.

What a Self-Hosted Shop Still Pays For

Owning the shop does not mean escaping transaction fees. WooCommerce takes no commission, but every card payment still passes through a gateway, and the gateway charges for it. Stripe’s published UK rate, for example, is 1.5% plus 20p for standard UK cards, with higher rates for premium, business and international cards.

The fixed costs move too. An owned shop needs hosting, a domain, premium plugins for features such as advanced shipping or subscriptions, and someone to keep the software current. Those costs do not climb with your sales, and that is the main financial difference between the two models.

A Three-Year Fee Model for a Growing UK Shop

The table models the published fees for a shop with a £50 average order that grows from £60,000 to £120,000 in annual sales. It assumes Shopify Basic paid monthly through Shopify Payments, compared with an owned WooCommerce shop using Stripe at its standard UK card rate. These are estimates built from published rates, and your own card mix, refunds and overseas orders will change them.

FeeYear 1 (£60,000 sales)Year 2 (£90,000 sales)Year 3 (£120,000 sales)
Shopify Basic subscription£300£300£300
Shopify Payments card fees£1,500£2,250£3,000
Shopify total£1,800£2,550£3,300
Stripe card fees on an owned shop£1,140£1,710£2,280

Over the three years, the Shopify fees in this model come to £7,650 against £5,130 in gateway fees for the owned shop, a difference of £2,520. The gap is real, though smaller than many comparisons claim, and it narrows if the Shopify shop moves to a higher plan with a lower card rate.

The model leaves out costs that vary too widely to estimate fairly. On Shopify, add the theme, monthly app subscriptions and any custom development. On the WooCommerce side, add the build, which starts at £4,000 plus VAT for a new ProfileTree website, along with hosting, plugin licences and maintenance. For most shops, the decision turns less on fees and more on whether you would sooner pay as you grow or invest at the start and own the result. Our ecommerce build packages page sets out what each level of build includes.

Data, UK GDPR and the Cost of Leaving

You own your customer and order data on Shopify, but Shopify controls the system it sits in, and that matters on the day you decide to leave. Under UK GDPR, your business is the controller (the organisation responsible for the data), and Shopify acts as your processor under its data processing addendum.

Shopify’s documentation states that data from UK and EEA customers is first received by its Irish company, with cloud hosting in Canada, and that transfers out of the UK rely on adequacy arrangements for Canada and on standard contractual clauses. That is a recognised legal basis, and for most small shops it is sufficient. A business whose contracts or customers require UK-only storage will find that easier to demonstrate on a site hosted in a UK data centre.

Leaving takes planning. Products, customers and orders can be exported as CSV files, but customer passwords cannot be moved, so every account holder has to set a new password on the new shop. Order history usually needs a migration tool or a custom import, and every Shopify URL needs a 301 redirect (a permanent forwarding instruction) to its new address to protect the rankings the old pages earned.

An owned site moves more simply. You copy the files and the database to a new host, point the domain at it, and the URLs stay exactly as they were. Migration work in either direction varies with the size of the catalogue and the order history, so ProfileTree prices it by the hour and quotes it on request.

Which Model Fits Your Business Stage

The stage your business has reached is a better guide than any feature list. The descriptions below reflect the situations we meet most often, and they are a starting point for your own figures.

Shopify is likely to suit you if you are launching a first product or testing demand before committing larger sums. It also suits an owner without technical staff who wants one company accountable for the servers, security and the checkout, and a catalogue that fits a standard theme without unusual checkout rules.

A self-hosted website is likely to suit you once your sales are steady enough to justify the build and you want running costs that do not rise with every order. It is the stronger choice if content and organic search are central to how you win customers, or if you need custom checkout steps, trade pricing, or complex delivery rules that Shopify handles only through Plus or paid apps.

Some businesses run both. A WordPress site carries the content and the search work, and a Shopify store linked from it takes the payments. It adds a second system to maintain, but for a content-led brand with a modest catalogue it can be a sensible middle route.

Planning Your Shop Build or Move with ProfileTree

Your next step is to put your own figures against both models: current or expected sales, average order value, the apps or plugins you need, and the people who will look after the site. ProfileTree is a Belfast web design and digital marketing agency, founded in 2011 and based at the McSweeney Centre, and our team builds and maintains shops on both WooCommerce and Shopify, so the advice starts from your requirements.

“Whichever platform a shop runs on, the first question I ask a retailer in Belfast is what they will own when the build is finished. At ProfileTree we build online shops on WordPress and on Shopify, and the right platform follows from the stage the business has reached. The owner should always know what it costs to stay and what it would cost to leave.”

Ciaran Connolly, founder of ProfileTree

If you trade in Belfast, see how we approach website design for Belfast businesses. Wherever you are in the UK or Ireland, our website development team can scope a new shop, a WooCommerce build or a move away from Shopify, with a redirect plan agreed before anything goes live.

FAQs

1. Is Shopify Self-Hosted?

No, Shopify is not self-hosted. Shopify runs the software and the servers, and you rent access through a monthly plan, so you cannot install Shopify on your own hosting. A shop built on WordPress and WooCommerce runs on a server you choose and pay for. That gives you control of the location, the software, and the backups, and it makes you responsible for keeping them up to date.

2. Is It Better to Use Shopify or My Own Website?

The better option depends on the stage your business is at. Shopify usually wins for a first shop, a product test, or a business with no technical help, because you can launch within days and Shopify looks after the servers. A site you own usually wins once sales are steady, content and search matter to your growth, or you need checkout and pricing rules that Shopify restricts. Run your own sales figures through both before you decide.

3. Why Use Shopify Instead of Your Own Website?

The main reasons are speed and simplicity. Shopify gives you a working checkout, hosting, security, and card payments from the first day, with one company to contact when something breaks. For a seller testing demand or working without a developer, that removes most of the technical risk. The trade-off is a fee structure that rises with turnover and less control over design, URLs, and data.

4. What Is the Shopify Transaction Fee and Can I Avoid It?

Shopify charges a transaction fee of 2% on the Basic plan when an outside payment provider is your main gateway, falling to 1% on Grow and 0.6% on Advanced. You avoid it by using Shopify Payments, which charges its own card rate on every order. Card processing is never free on any platform, and a WooCommerce shop pays its own gateway’s rate.

5. Can I Move My Shopify Store to WordPress Without Losing Customers?

You can move without losing customers, provided the migration is planned. Products, customers, and orders can be exported, but customer passwords cannot, so account holders need to set a new password after the move. Email them before launch so the reset does not come as a surprise. Order history needs an import tool or custom work, and every old URL needs a 301 redirect to keep your search rankings.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.Required fields are marked *

Web Design

Web Design

We design stunning, user focused websites that present your brand beautifully and convert visitors into customers.

Web Development

Web Development

We use the latest development tools to build websites that are optimised for peak performance at all times.

Website Management

Website Hosting

We manage everything from site updates and reports to hosting, allowing you to focus on running your business.

Search Engine Optimisation

Search Engine Optimisation

Using the latest SEO techniques, we help your brand get found for the right terms and by the right people.

Digital Marketing Strategy

Digital Marketing Strategy

Navigate the digital landscape with a marketing strategy. Our team crafts comprehensive plans that resonate with your target audience, drive engagement, and boost conversions.

Digital Marketing Training

Digital Marketing Training

Elevate your digital proficiency. Our in-depth training sessions equip your business with cutting-edge digital marketing techniques to outperform competitors and thrive online.

Social Media Strategy

Social Media Strategy

Captivate and grow your social following. We create tailored social media strategies that ignite engagement, amplify your brand's online presence, and foster lasting connections.

Email Marketing Solutions

Email Marketing Solutions

Harness the power of your mailing list. Our precision-targeted email marketing campaigns are engineered to nurture relationships and drive tangible business outcomes.

Content Marketing Services

Content Marketing Services

Elevate your brand with our content marketing mastery. From thought-provoking blogs to eye-catching infographics, we craft content that captivates, informs, and converts your ideal audience.

Video Production

Video Production

Capture your audience with compelling video content. Our production team creates visual stories that engage, inform, and leave a lasting impression.

Brand Storytelling

Brand Storytelling

Bring your brand's story to life with authenticity. We craft compelling narratives that strike a chord with your audience, forging a powerful emotional bond with your brand.

Content Strategy Development

Content Strategy Development

Strategic content that drives action. We develop content strategies that align with your business goals, ensuring every piece of content counts.

AI Training

AI Training

Empower your business with AI expertise. Our tailored training demystifies AI, equipping your team with the knowledge to leverage its potential for growth and innovation.

AI Chatbots

AI Chatbots

Transform customer service with AI chatbots. We develop sophisticated chatbots that elevate user experience, streamline interactions, and deliver unparalleled efficiency.

AI Marketing

AI Marketing

Transform your reach with AI-driven marketing. Harness data-driven insights for laser-targeted campaigns that captivate, engage, and convert your audience.

AI Tools for Business

AI Tools for Business

Optimise your operations with cutting-edge AI tools. We integrate intelligent solutions that streamline processes, enhance efficiency, and support data-driven decision-making.

Join Our Mailing List

Grow your business with expert web design, AI strategies and digital marketing tips straight to your inbox. Subscribe to our newsletter.