“The best way to get one link is to create something truly great that links to naturally.”—Rand Fishkin, SEO expert.

While Fishkin emphasises the power of naturally acquired backlinks, the reality is that creating such content consistently and waiting for organic links can be a slow process. This is where the backlink conundrum comes in; you need backlinks, but acquiring high-quality, relevant ones can be:

• Time-consuming: Manually reaching out to website owners and persuading them to link back to your website requires significant effort.
• Competitive: Many websites are vying for the same valuable backlinks.

This is where broken link building emerges as a strategic and efficient solution to overcoming the backlink conundrum. It leverages a common issue on the web—broken links—and turns it into an opportunity to build valuable backlinks for your website.

---

The ever-evolving landscape of SEO can feel like a never-ending puzzle. While you meticulously craft compelling content and optimise your website for search engines, backlinks remain a crucial piece. These digital endorsements from other websites hold immense power in shaping your website’s search rankings.

The challenge is that building high-quality, relevant backlinks is both time-consuming and competitive. This is where broken link building steps in as a game-changer.

Broken links abound on the internet. For instance, researchers found that 39% to 83% of the links in academic journals no longer work. The good news is that website owners can use them to their advantage. Broken link building has become a popular strategy among search marketers because it provides an ethical, spam-free way to gain quality one-way links.

Broken link building is a highly effective SEO tactic that involves finding 404 pages on relevant websites and providing value by fixing those broken links. This comprehensive guide will explore proven strategies for identifying broken link opportunities, prioritising outreach, conducting campaigns at scale, and earning high-authority backlinks to boost your search rankings.

Broken Link Building: How It Works

When a website contains broken or outdated links, it becomes less useful and can lose credibility. This can also negatively impact its search engine rankings. As a result, webmasters often appreciate being informed about these bad links so they can remove or update them.

You can take advantage of this by identifying broken links, reporting them to the website owner, and suggesting a link to your own relevant content as a replacement. This way, you help the webmaster while earning a valuable backlink. Some SEO specialists use different variations of this strategy to maximise its effectiveness.

Finding Broken Link Opportunities

The first step in broken link building is to locate resource pages that focus on subjects relevant to your website. Moz.com suggests searching for terms like “recommended resources,” “related websites,” “suggested sites,” “useful websites,” or “favourite links.” Combine these phrases with one or two keywords describing your website. You’ll find pages that contain numerous links, so there’s a high probability that some of them will be broken.

Here are powerful tools and techniques to discover broken links on authoritative pages in your industry:

• Ahrefs: Use the Backlink Checker and filter for 404 errors. Export broken page lists as CSV files for easier analysis.
• Screaming Frog: Crawl entire websites, filter for response codes, and then export the 404 list of broken pages.
• Linkody: This tool is designed specifically for finding broken links. It syncs with Gmail for seamless outreach.
• Manual Search: Perform Google searches targeting specific sites by using “site.com 404” to uncover broken pages.

Check key competitors, resource sites, and established publications for high-value broken link building opportunities.

While resource or link pages are the primary targets for broken link building, other types of web content can also offer valuable opportunities. For instance, outdated links in news articles, blog entries, or buying guides may also serve as potential prospects. Any relevant webpage with external links can be useful for this strategy.

Prioritising Potential Targets

Once you’ve compiled a list of broken links, the next step is to determine which outreach targets are the most valuable. Prioritise pages that:

• Are directly related to your service, product, or niche to ensure relevance.
• Reside on authoritative domains with strong trust metrics.
• Have substantial search traffic and keyword opportunities.
• Are strategic fits, such as link-building resources for an SEO brand.
• Show signs of reader engagement, such as social shares, comments, or other indicators of reader value.
• Have been published recently, ideally within the past year.

Crafting Effective Outreach

To earn links, your outreach pitch must provide value to website owners. Follow these best practices for effective outreach:

• Personalise each email: Tailor each email specifically to the broken page and your suggestions. Avoid using generic templates.
• Provide context: Explain who you are and why you were browsing their website. This helps establish credibility.
• Limit the number of links: Offer to share relevant recommendations if they’re open to it, but avoid overwhelming them with too many links.
• Be helpful: Focus on fixing issues and adding value. The link is a bonus, not the sole objective.
• Include screenshots and specific details: Make the process as easy as possible by providing clear examples and details.

By following these tips, your outreach will be more compelling and likely to result in successful link building opportunities.

Scaling Campaigns

Manual outreach is effective but can be time-consuming. To scale your broken link building efforts, consider automating parts of the process:

• Use software: Tools like Linkody, Pitchbox, or Mailshake can help with email sequencing, follow-ups, and tracking.
• Automate broken link discovery: Use bots or scripts designed for major tools to automate the process of finding broken links.
• Test in small batches: Begin with small batch tests to refine your process before scaling.
• Prioritise manual efforts: Focus your manual efforts only on the highest-value targets and automate the rest.
• Rotate proxy IPs: If needed, rotate proxies to avoid bot detection when crawling websites.

When used correctly, automation can greatly amplify the effectiveness of your broken link building campaigns.

Fixing Broken Links: A Practical Guide

Broken links can frustrate your visitors and hurt your website’s SEO. Fixing them is crucial for maintaining a user-friendly website and optimising your SEO performance. This guide provides a step-by-step approach to resolving them effectively.

1. Identifying Broken Link Causes

Broken links occur for several reasons, and identifying the root cause is the first step. Common causes include:

• Page Relocations: URLs change when content is moved to new sections of your website.
• Outdated Content: Pages that have been deleted or archived result in broken links.
• Incorrect Link Formatting: Errors in the URL structure, such as typos or missing slashes, can lead to non-functional links.

2. Locating Broken Links

To fix broken links, you first need to find them. Here’s how to locate them:

• Website Analytics: Tools like Google Search Console can highlight pages with broken links and 404 errors.
• Error Logs: Many web hosting services provide logs that show broken links and related issues.
• User Feedback: Encourage users to report broken links to you or look for comments or messages pointing out issues.

3. Redirecting Broken Links

Once broken links are identified, redirect them to the appropriate pages using 301 redirects. This ensures users are taken to the correct destination, preventing the loss of traffic and improving user experience. Here’s how:

• For WordPress: Use a plugin like Redirection to easily manage 301 redirects.
• Manually: Add 301 redirect rules to your website’s .htaccess file if you’re comfortable with server-side configurations.

4. Removing Orphaned Pages

Orphaned pages are those with no internal links pointing to them, which can negatively impact your website’s structure and SEO. To address this:

• Identify orphaned pages: Use tools like Screaming Frog to scan your website for pages without internal links.
• Remove or re-link: If the content is outdated or irrelevant, consider removing these pages. Otherwise, create internal links to these pages from relevant content to improve navigation and structure.

By following these steps, you’ll not only fix broken links but also enhance the overall usability and SEO of your website.

Preventing Broken Links: A Proactive Approach

Proactive link management is key to minimising the occurrence of broken links and maintaining a healthy, user-friendly website. Here are several strategies to prevent broken links before they become an issue:

1. Thorough Link Testing

Ensure that all links are tested during website development and after making any changes to the content or site structure. This includes:

• Testing both internal and external links during the design phase.
• Re-checking links after publishing new content or updates to ensure everything remains functional.
• Testing links in different browsers and devices to avoid any compatibility issues.

2. Regular Link Audits

Conducting regular link audits helps you catch and fix broken links before they negatively impact user experience and SEO. Here’s how:

• Schedule audits: Set up monthly or quarterly link audits to scan your website for broken or outdated links.
• Use tools: Employ tools like Screaming Frog or Ahrefs to automate the process and ensure thorough checks across all pages.

3. Content Management System (CMS) Updates

Keep your Content Management System (CMS) and plugins up to date to prevent link breakage caused by software changes or security vulnerabilities. Here are some tips:

• Backup first: Always back up your website before applying updates.
• Monitor after updates: Check links after every update to ensure there are no disruptions.

4. Link Monitoring Tools

Utilise link monitoring tools to stay ahead of broken link issues. These tools alert you when a link becomes broken, allowing you to address it promptly. Some effective tools include:

• Google Search Console: Provides regular reports on broken links and 404 errors.
• Ahrefs or SEMrush: These SEO tools include link monitoring features that notify you of broken external and internal links.
• Linkody: Specifically designed to monitor broken links and simplify the process of fixing them.

By adopting these proactive link management practices, you can significantly reduce the frequency of broken links, ensuring a smooth user experience and maintaining your website’s SEO health

Testing Process

Manually testing each link on desirable pages can be time-consuming, but you can speed up the process by using automated tools to check for broken links. Some helpful software includes:

• Check My Links: A Chrome extension that quickly scans web pages for broken links.
• Xenu’s Link Sleuth: A desktop application that checks entire websites for broken links.
• Screaming Frog SEO: A versatile tool for crawling websites and identifying broken links, among other SEO issues.

It’s important to double-check any link before reporting it, as these programs may not always provide completely accurate data.

Contacting Websites

“Broken link building can be VERY rewarding for consistently growing your traffic over time,” says SEO expert Richard Marriott. However, only a small percentage of webmasters will choose to link to your website. This makes it crucial to use your time efficiently. A well-crafted, friendly email template can help you reach out to more websites effectively.

Here are some key strategies for crafting an email:

• Polite and concise: Write a brief, polite message and personalise it for each recipient. Avoid overwhelming webmasters with long emails, as lengthy messages are more likely to be ignored or postponed.
• Personalisation is key: Avoid generic form letters by mentioning specific details about the website and the page with the broken link you’re referencing. This personal touch shows you’ve put effort into your outreach.

Single vs. Multiple-Step Approach

Most marketers send all the necessary information in a single email. However, some use a multi-step approach:

1. First email: Inform the webmaster about the broken link.
2. Follow-up: If they respond, suggest linking to your website and potentially introduce other ideas, such as writing a guest blog post.

This method can be worth experimenting with, as it may lead to more engagement.

Going the Extra Mile

Some webmasters will appreciate extra effort. For instance, you could:

• Provide multiple suggestions: Offer several high-quality replacement URLs for multiple broken links, including only one of your own.
• Research the original content: If you find where the broken link’s content has moved, share the updated URL along with your own suggestion.

These approaches increase your chances of building valuable links while helping webmasters improve their sites.

Contact Details

To succeed in your outreach, finding the right contact information is essential. Here are some tips for locating it:

• Check resource pages: Look at the introduction or conclusion for any email addresses or contact details.
• Explore the “About Us” page: Many websites include emails or contact forms here, and some may provide a staff directory.
• Look for personal contacts: For a more personalised approach, aim to send your message to a specific person and address them by name.

Additional Tips

• Titles: Keep titles simple—”Dr.” or “Professor” is appropriate, but avoid long or unnecessary formalities.
• Facebook “About” pages: These often include contact info for organisations and websites.
• Greeting: If you can’t find a name, start your message with “Hi” to keep it friendly but professional.

You can also try using automated “contact finder” tools, though they can be unreliable. In some cases, a website may only offer postal mail or phone contact details. If a link is particularly valuable, it might be worth the effort and cost to send a physical letter, as printed correspondence is often taken more seriously than emails.

Prioritisation

When conducting a broken link building campaign, it’s crucial to prioritise high-quality web pages that are likely to accept your links. Here are a few guidelines to follow:

• Focus on authority sites: Authoritative nonprofit, educational, and government websites usually provide the most valuable link opportunities.
• Relevance matters: Ensure the website and the content are relevant to your niche. Links from unrelated or low-quality websites can harm your SEO efforts.
• Check for recent updates: Prioritise websites that have been updated recently. Old resource pages with no updates in years are less likely to result in responses. If a resource list has remained the same since 1998, the likelihood of a response is low. The person who maintains it may have retired or decided to abandon the list.
• Consider page popularity: Webmasters are more likely to care about broken links on pages that receive significant traffic.

Focus on web pages with broken outbound links whenever possible, as webmasters are more likely to add your link when fixing these. If you only find broken internal links, it’s still worth a try—especially on high-value websites. Just be sure to suggest where your link could be added.

Tracking Progress

Keeping track of your outreach efforts is crucial to ensure efficiency and avoid redundancy. Here’s how to effectively manage your link building process:

• Maintain a contact list: Record all the websites and individuals you’ve reached out to. This helps prevent repeated emails to the same person, which could waste time and lead to “spam” complaints.
• Monitor websites: Occasionally revisit the websites you’ve contacted, as some webmasters may create links without notifying you.
• Log successful outcomes: Update your list whenever a link is successfully added. This helps you measure progress and focus on strategies that work.

Optimising Your Approach

If your outreach doesn’t yield results, it may be time to refine your strategy:

• Review your email template: Ensure it’s engaging, concise, and clearly explains the value of your link. If responses are lacking, consider tweaking your message.
• Evaluate your content quality: Webmasters prefer linking to high-quality, well-edited, and valuable content. Make sure your webpage is compelling, informative, and visually appealing, as this increases the likelihood of gaining backlinks.

In Addition

• Use a spreadsheet or database: This will help you track your progress and identify potential follow-ups.
• Set reminders: Follow up with websites that haven’t responded after a reasonable amount of time.
• Analyse your results: Track which outreach strategies are most effective and adjust your approach accordingly.

By tracking your progress and continuously improving your outreach and content, you’ll increase your chances of successful link building.

Advanced Strategies for Broken Link Building

To maximise the effectiveness of broken link building, you can go beyond traditional methods and adopt advanced strategies. Here are two powerful techniques:

1. Recreate Defunct Content

Developing new content to replace a common broken link is a smart way to boost your chances of gaining backlinks. Here’s how:

• Use the Wayback Machine: Visit the Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine to view the content of defunct pages. This allows you to see what the original page offered and create something similar or better.
• Example: You may run a website selling AM/FM radios. You notice several websites have dead links to an outdated list of radio stations in London. Think about building a similar page and suggesting it as a replacement.
• Best Practices:
  • Take the time to create detailed, high-quality material
  • Surpass the old page with insightful, up-to-date content
  • Briefly advertise your product or service at the end to avoid over-commercialising the content.

2. Register Expired Domains

Another advanced technique involves identifying bad links that point to expired domains. This allows you to register the domain and reestablish web pages using the appropriate URLs. You would need to pay the registration fee and a yearly renewal charge. Nonetheless, it may be worth the expense if an expired domain still has numerous high-quality inbound links.

Rather than manually looking up each domain name, you can use a handy browser extension called Domain Hunter Plus. It automatically searches for bad links and tells you if their domains have expired. This tool even calculates the total number of links to a defunct domain, so you may easily gauge its value.

Why These Strategies Work

Broken link building requires time and effort but remains one of the most cost-effective ways to gain valuable inbound backlinks without spending heavily on paid strategies. Additionally, it involves comparatively little risk. As long as you keep away from suspicious websites and avoid offering incentives, you’re unlikely to face any search engine penalties.

Why Choose Professional Support

Hence, the benefits of using one of the best content marketing agencies are clear. Working with one can offer a significant return on investment by helping you develop exceptional content that attracts high-quality inbound links. Content marketing is integral to link building, and this strategy likely led you to this article today. If you need assistance with SEO, copywriting, or developing an optimised website, feel free to contact our team for professional guidance.

Identifying High-Value Broken Links in 2024: Latest Best Practices and Trends

Broken link building continues to be a highly effective SEO strategy in 2024, but to identify and capitalise on high-value opportunities, you need to stay up to date with the latest best practices and trends. Here’s how to refine your approach:

1. Data-Driven Targeting with Advanced Tools

• Go beyond basic broken link checkers: While tools like Screaming Frog and Ahrefs remain essential, explore more advanced options like LinkMiner, Broken Link Builder, or Check My Links for better filtering and ranking capabilities.
• Refine search criteria: Focus not only on finding broken links but also on filtering by domain authority, topical relevance, anchor text, and website traffic. This will help prioritise high-value opportunities.
• Leverage competitor analysis: Use competitor SEO analysis tools to identify broken links within their backlink profiles. This lets you target opportunities where your content can provide a clear advantage.

2. Prioritising Quality and Relevance

• Content First: Don’t just replace a broken link with any relevant page. Ensure your content is superior, offering greater value and a better user experience that aligns with the original topic.
• Topical Relevance: Prioritise websites within your niche or closely related industries to create contextually relevant backlinks that boost SEO power.
• Language and Region Consideration: When seeking international opportunities, ensure you target websites in the same language and region as your audience for greater alignment.

3. Automation and Personalisation in Outreach

• Streamline outreach: Utilise outreach automation tools like Zapier or Pabbly Connect to send personalised emails more efficiently without compromising on individual attention.
• Personalise beyond templates: While templates save time, go the extra mile by customising each message to address the specific website, highlighting the value your content offers and addressing their exact broken link issue.
• Showcase social proof: Include statistics on your website traffic, positive testimonials, or social media engagement to demonstrate the value your content can bring.

4. Building Relationships and Ethical Outreach

• Focus on genuine connections: Engage with website owners through social media or insightful blog comments before initiating outreach. Building a relationship first can improve your success rate.
• Transparency and Respect: Clearly explain the broken link issue and offer your relevant content as a valuable solution rather than a forced exchange.
• Offer alternatives: If a direct replacement isn’t available, suggest other relevant content on your website that could benefit their audience.
• Stay ethical: Comply with Google’s guidelines by avoiding manipulative tactics like link buying or keyword stuffing. Instead, focus on delivering genuine value through ethical outreach practices.

Bonus Trends

• Broken Link Building for Local SEO: Target geographically relevant websites and online directories to improve local search rankings.
• Leverage HARO Queries: Respond to relevant “Help a Reporter Out” queries where your content can replace broken links in future articles.
• Expand to Broken Image and Resource Links: Don’t limit your efforts to textual links. Seek out broken images, infographics, or resource links and offer your own high-quality alternatives.

Remember, broken link building is a long-term SEO strategy that requires consistent effort. By applying these best practices, prioritising quality and relevance, and embracing the latest trends in 2024, you’ll be better positioned to identify high-value opportunities and secure impactful backlinks. The rewards include enhanced search rankings, improved visibility, and sustained SEO benefits over time.

Conclusion

Identifying and fixing broken links is crucial for maintaining a healthy, user-friendly, and search engine-friendly website. Broken links can negatively affect user experience and hurt your website’s rankings, making it essential to address them promptly. By applying the strategies and tools discussed, you can efficiently manage broken links and optimise your website’s performance.

With the right approach, you’re well-positioned to enhance your website’s quality, improve user satisfaction, and achieve your online goals. Broken link building is a proven tactic that, when executed with creativity and persistence, allows you to build valuable relationships with publishers and earn high-quality editorial links. Systematically implementing this strategy will lead to significant SEO gains over time.

FAQ