In this article, we will discuss the ethics and legalities of digital marketing. As a business, it is of utmost importance to ensure that your digital marketing operates within the boundaries of ethics and legalities in digital marketing. Otherwise, it could spoil your reputation and damage your brand.
As digital marketing takes centre stage, knowing where to draw the line can be a bit blurred. Social media sites and other online platforms can be a bit risqué or controversial depending on the user and topic. As a business, how do you engage your audience while still maintaining professional distance from personal opinions?
Table of Contents
What Are The Ethics and Legalities of Digital Marketing?
Digital marketing is the process of promoting a brand using a variety of online tactics. These tactics include having a website, blogs, social media, and mobile marketing. Although, unlike traditional advertising, the reach occurs almost instantaneously and is more engaged with the audience. The advertising is also more sophisticated and can be tailored to specific audiences.
The sharp rise in new technologies has meant the rise in unprecedented challenges. Many of the ethical and legal considerations could not have been anticipated until they had already caused problems; the challenge now is to quickly adapt to this ever-changing landscape and ensure safe and responsible practices within digital marketing.
The digital media landscape is continuously evolving, and with it comes a range of ethical issues that impact individuals and society at large. There are several things to consider when dealing with the ethics and legalities of digital marketing, including;
Lack of Transparency
Digital platforms and online services often have complex algorithms determining what content is shown to users. However, the lack of transparency regarding how these algorithms work and what data is being collected and used can be a major ethical concern. Additionally, online advertising and sponsored content can sometimes be presented in a way that is unclear to the audience, further exacerbating the lack of transparency issue.
Ownership of Information
The digital age has blurred the lines regarding ownership and control of information. Issues surrounding copyright, data ownership, and intellectual property have become more complex. For instance, when individuals upload content to social media platforms, there can be ambiguity regarding who owns that content and how it can be used by others, including the platforms themselves.
Concerns of Trust and Integrity
The anonymity and vastness of digital media can sometimes undermine trust and integrity. For example, fake reviews on e-commerce or review sites can mislead consumers, and anonymous trolling can create a toxic online environment. Moreover, the integrity of digital media platforms can be questioned when they are used for nefarious purposes, such as spreading hate or enabling harassment.
Misinformation and False News
The rapid dissemination of information online can also lead to the spread of misinformation and false news. Without proper verification mechanisms, false information can spread widely and quickly, leading to public confusion, panic, or misinformed decision-making. The prevalence of “fake news” has been a significant concern, especially during critical times like elections or public health crises.
Echo Chambers
Digital media platforms often utilize algorithms to show users content that aligns with their existing beliefs, interests, and interactions. This can create “echo chambers” or “filter bubbles” where individuals are only exposed to information and opinions similar to their own, thereby reinforcing their existing beliefs and isolating them from diverse perspectives. This lack of exposure to diverse viewpoints can contribute to polarization and a lack of understanding or tolerance for differing opinions.
These ethical issues in digital media pose significant challenges and call for a thorough examination by policymakers, platform operators, and the general public. Addressing these issues may require a combination of legal, technological, and educational approaches to promote transparency, trust, and ethical conduct in the digital media landscape.
Legalities of digital marketing guidelines
In the bigger realm of things, it may also be wise to follow standards of conduct based on the American Bar Association (ABA). They have specific guidelines discussing advertising, blogging rules, social media, and marketing activity. While the rules change based on state, having your general counsel develop a set of rules and regulations based on these documents can cover you if any legal matters come to light.
Here is a general overview:
- False statements – Don’t do it. When advertising and using social media, it is important to be as transparent and truthful as possible. Users appreciate brands that can own up to their flaws, missteps and mistakes.
- False promises – Don’t do it. You should be able to stand by every statement you make regarding promotions and advertising. If you are advertising a prize, make sure you stick to the terms and conditions. Any deviation could be a social nightmare.
Understanding the pitfalls of improper marketing tactics will help you develop a campaign that is both socially and morally responsible and within the legalities of digital marketing.
Ethics of Marketing
Marketing ethics refers to the area of applied ethics which deals with the moral principles behind the operation and regulation of marketing. Some areas of marketing ethics (ethics of advertising and promotion) overlap with media and public relations ethics. Whether it’s via traditional print or an online medium, ethical considerations remain a constant.
Here are several key points to consider for the ethics of marketing:
- Truthfulness and Honesty:
- All marketing messages should be truthful and not misleading. Companies must avoid making false claims about their products or services.
- Transparency:
- Transparency in marketing means being open and honest with customers about pricing, product ingredients or materials, and other key information.
- Privacy:
- Respecting customer privacy is crucial, especially when it comes to handling customer data and using it for marketing purposes.
- Fair Competition:
- Ethical marketing practices encourage fair competition and ensure that companies compete fairly and honestly.
- Cultural Sensitivity:
- Marketers should be sensitive to different cultures and avoid creating messages that could be offensive or misunderstood.
- Sustainability:
- Ethical marketing can also extend to promoting sustainability and ensuring that marketing practices are environmentally friendly.
- Consumer Autonomy:
- Marketing practices should not manipulate or coerce consumers into making purchases they would not otherwise make.
- Disclosure:
- If there are any affiliations, sponsorships, or other business relationships that could affect the objectivity of marketing, these should be disclosed.
- Pricing Integrity:
- Ethical pricing strategies are fundamental to ethical marketing. This involves being transparent and fair in pricing, avoiding price fixing, price discrimination, or deceptive pricing.
- Legal Compliance:
- Abiding by the laws and regulations governing marketing practices is a basic requisite for ethical marketing.
- Responsible Representation:
- Representing products or services responsibly and accurately, avoiding exaggeration or misrepresentation.
- Consumer Education:
- Providing consumers with adequate information to make informed decisions.
Adhering to ethical principles in marketing not only builds trust with customers but also improves a company’s reputation and mitigates legal issues. Moreover, it fosters a culture of integrity within the organization, which can have long-term benefits for both the company and its stakeholders. Ethical marketing is about making marketing decisions that are morally right and just.
Why Are The Legalities of Digital Marketing Important?
Legal and ethical constraints are crucial in marketing plan development to ensure that organizations conduct their marketing activities in a manner that is fair, honest, and beneficial to both the company and its stakeholders. Here are several reasons why these constraints are essential:
- Consumer Protection:
- Legal and ethical constraints are designed to protect consumers from misleading information, fraud, and other harmful practices. They ensure that the marketing activities are truthful, accurate, and fair.
- Competitive Fairness:
- They promote fair competition among businesses by preventing deceptive marketing practices, plagiarism, and other unfair competitive practices.
- Regulatory Compliance:
- Legal constraints ensure the marketing plan complies with the various laws and regulations governing marketing practices. This compliance is vital to avoid legal penalties, fines, or other sanctions.
- Reputation Management:
- Ethical marketing practices contribute to building and maintaining a good reputation. Conversely, unethical practices can severely damage a company’s reputation and customer trust.
- Privacy and Data Protection:
- With the increasing amount of data collected for marketing purposes, legal and ethical constraints ensure that companies respect privacy rights and protect customer data.
- Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR):
- Ethical constraints encourage companies to engage in responsible marketing practices that reflect a commitment to CSR, contributing to societal well-being and environmental sustainability.
- Long-term Success:
- Following legal and ethical guidelines can contribute to the long-term success of a company. Ethical marketing can lead to better relationships with customers, suppliers, and other stakeholders.
- Transparency and Disclosure:
- Legal and ethical guidelines promote transparency and full disclosure, ensuring consumers have the information they need to make informed decisions.
- Avoidance of Legal Litigation:
- Adhering to legal constraints helps in avoiding costly and time-consuming legal battles, which can also tarnish the company’s image.
- Global Marketing Standards:
- For companies operating globally, understanding and adhering to both legal and ethical constraints is crucial to navigating the different legal and cultural landscapes effectively.
- Informed Public:
- Ethical and legal constraints help ensure that the public is well-informed and not misled, contributing to a more informed and educated consumer base.
These constraints, while they may seem restrictive, play a pivotal role in creating a more level playing field in the market, protecting stakeholders, and ensuring that companies maintain a high level of integrity in their marketing practices.
Digital marketing is both incredibly new and incredibly powerful; the rise of the internet means that just about anyone has the power to shape the beliefs of a large chunk of the general public. It is now more important than ever for policymakers, marketing professionals and regulators to ensure that they remain aware of how they can better protect their customers and stakeholders through continually abiding by the ethical code and legalities of digital marketing.
What are some Ethical Issues in Social Media?
The rapid growth and widespread use of social media platforms have brought to light several ethical issues. Here are some of the notable ethical concerns associated with social media:
- Privacy and Data Security:
- Social media platforms collect vast amounts of personal data. The handling, sharing, and protection of this data are major ethical concerns, especially when users are unaware or uninformed about how their data is being used.
- Misinformation and Disinformation:
- Social media is a common platform for the spread of misinformation (incorrect or misleading information spread without malicious intent) and disinformation (deliberately falsified information spread to deceive others).
- Cyberbullying:
- The anonymity or the impersonal nature of social media can sometimes embolden individuals to engage in harassment, bullying, or hateful speech.
- Addiction:
- Social media addiction is a growing concern, with individuals spending excessive amounts of time on these platforms, which can negatively affect mental health.
- Echo Chambers and Filter Bubbles:
- Social media algorithms often show users content that aligns with their existing beliefs or preferences, creating echo chambers or filter bubbles that reinforce existing viewpoints and isolate users from diverse perspectives.
- Manipulative Advertising and Marketing:
- Some advertising and marketing practices on social media can be manipulative, leveraging sophisticated algorithms to target individuals based on their personal data and preferences.
- Fake Accounts and Impersonation:
- The creation of fake accounts or impersonation of individuals and organizations is a significant ethical issue that can cause reputational damage or facilitate fraudulent activities.
- Intellectual Property Theft:
- Sharing and distributing copyrighted materials without permission or proper attribution is common on social media, which infringes on intellectual property rights.
- Political Manipulation:
- Social media can be used for political manipulation, for instance, by spreading propaganda or engaging in astroturfing (the practice of masking the sponsors of a message to make it appear as though it originates from grassroots participants).
- Bias and Discrimination:
- There’s a concern about algorithmic bias, where the algorithms used by social media platforms may inadvertently perpetuate existing societal biases.
- Inappropriate Content:
- The posting and sharing of inappropriate or harmful content and the adequacy of content moderation practices by social media platforms are ongoing ethical issues.
- Employee Monitoring:
- Employers monitoring employees’ social media activities without consent or overly punitive policies regarding social media use can also raise ethical concerns.
These issues underline the multifaceted ethical landscape of social media, necessitating ongoing discussions and efforts among stakeholders, including platform providers, users, policymakers, and the broader society, to address these concerns and promote ethical social media use.
With so many ethical and legal issues present in the digital marketing space, how can companies successfully balance these issues in that space? Several things can be done to counteract ethical and legal issues for your organisation; check out some of the resources we have listed below.
Ethical Digital Marketing Books and Resources
Check out these resources to help guide your digital marketing strategy with attention to social and moral responsibility.
- Books on Ethical Digital Marketing:
- “Digital Media Ethics, 3rd Edition” by Charles Ess discusses the ethical issues of digital media from a global, cross-cultural perspective, exploring topics like Big Data, AI, and the Internet of Things.
- “Answers for Ethical Marketers: A Guide to Good Practice in…” is a book that addresses ethical questions around technology, media, and communication landscape changes, emphasizing the application of ethics across various media channels.
- “Ethical Marketing and The New Consumer” by Chris Arnold explores the growing consumer movement towards ethical products and how marketers can adapt to this trend.
- The “SAGE Handbook of Digital Marketing” has a section on Ethical Issues in Digital Marketing4.
- Online Guides and Resources:
- “2022 Guide to Ethical Digital Marketing” from JB Media Group discusses the principles of ethical marketing, honesty in digital marketing, and how to avoid dishonest marketing practices.
- A guide on “How to Be Ethical in Digital Marketing” by UpCity emphasizes the importance of having mechanisms in place to monitor ethical practices in digital marketing.
- Articles and Blog Posts:
- “The Ethics of Digital Marketing” by Digital Delane discusses digital marketing ethics as an integral part of the hyper-connected world we live in, delving into considerations that underpin digital marketing efforts to build trust.
- General Digital Marketing Books with Sections on Ethics:
- Some digital marketing books like “Digital Marketing for Dummies” and “Digital Branding” as mentioned in the “Top 20 Digital Marketing Books Every Marketer Must Read” by UMass, have sections that deal with ethical and data management challenges.
These resources encompass a wide range of topics within the realm of ethical digital marketing, covering aspects from consumer behaviour changes to legal and ethical guidelines for practising digital marketing.
Legal Issues In Online Marketing
The company must be committed to being ethically and legally responsible for every move made through digital media. If not, the company faces legal implications. This could be as simple as having a disclaimer throughout your digital advertising pieces. Your marketing team should operate with the highest ethical standards, avoiding questionable posts that could harm the brand.
In every promotion or contest, there needs to be a disclosure so your audiences will not feel as if they have been deceived. This is very simple. Either has a link that leads to the terms and conditions or adds a line at the bottom with pertinent information to make sure the organisation has operated with the best ethical judgement and the highest legal standards. Because brands are accountable for disclosing information to their audiences, it is wise to take the proper steps to remain protected.
Here are a few suggestions:
Media Kit
This should be provided to all the influencers and bloggers the company employs. It should include the best practices you follow as an organisation, along with other facts about the company. This way, your company will have legal standing if a blogger or influencer misrepresents the brand.
Have an Authentic Network
This is key. If you have a strong network of influencers who are familiar with the brand and your ethical standing, you will not have to worry about whether or not they will misrepresent your brand.
Media Audits
Your marketing team should track your social content quarterly to ensure your posts are clearly labelled. If you find some of those posts are not in compliance, you can track the influencers and have them make the fix.
Use the Word “Sponsored”
This is a quick and easy way to ensure your digital media is always covered. Using the word “sponsored” on all your digital campaigns and other media will alert your audiences it is a sponsored post from your brand.
Open the Lines of Communication
When using digital media, it is best to maintain an open-door policy and communicate with your audiences consistently. This not only helps build brand integrity but can help in the event of a mishap. When audiences trust you, it is easier for them to forgive a mistake than disgruntled customers who make things worse by sharing their experiences on social media.
On the legal side, there are three main issues affecting digital marketers:
Privacy and Data Collection
To be legally compliant, you must notify people before collecting their personal information, although the UK may have more permissive laws for current customers. It is important to list in your privacy policy the types of information you collect, how you share the information, the process that will allow those customers to review and change their information; and the policy’s effective date. If policy changes are made, those dates must also be included.
A privacy policy on your site specifically states that moving on through the site will be an agreement to collect their information is key. If you need to take it a step further, add a box that will solidify their agreement.
Legalities of Digital Marketing: GDPR
Of course, we can’t discuss the legal and ethical constraints on marketing plans without mentioning GDPR. This is the most comprehensive data protection regulation in the world. It was about after the EU recognised the protection of personal data as a human right in 2009.
This throws up several legal, regulatory and ethical constraints in sales or marketing. The core principles of the GDPR which impact the ethics of digital marketing include:
- Consent,
- Purpose limitation,
- Limits on data transfers,
- Breach reporting requirements,
- Limits on automated data processing.
This introduced a large number of legal and ethical constraints in marketing. Indeed, an ethical social media agency must now have a wide variety of policies and procedures in place to ensure ongoing GDPR compliance for their clients.
Cloud Storage and Security Methods
You must ensure all customers know you have protocols to secure their sensitive information. There should also be disclaimers on how this is done and whether or not your information-gathering process is SSL-protected.
Intellectual Property
This is by far the most complicated issue facing digital marketing. Protecting your intellectual property through trademarks and copyrights is crucial in this day and age. It is also just as important to ensure you have not used anyone else’s trademark or copyright.
How can you accomplish this?
- Register your trademark.
- Copyright your marketing language.
Taking these measures will ensure that you are working within the legalities of digital marketing and not causing problems or issues with other creators.
Anti Spam
Under the FTC, all advertising and marketing must be above board with no unfair or deceptive advertising elements. There is also an anti-spam law in effect in the US, which is called CAN-SPAM, which could affect your global digital marketing efforts. Several guidelines under the CAN-SPAM Act should be followed for compliance.
Having an attorney / legal professional working with your marketing team will assist in drafting ethics and legal policies for your organisation that will protect you in every aspect of your digital marketing efforts. Understanding the ethics and legalities of digital marketing can help your company avoid litigation and questions about your ethical integrity now and in the future.
Legal, Ethical and Social Aspects of Advertising Online
Let’s look at a couple of concrete ways that digital marketing ethics will actually impact your online campaigns. We’ll start with display ads, as these are probably the places where online marketing ethics have the most obvious impact.
An online ad essentially has two components:
- Creativity – Including elements like written copy, imagery, videos and landing pages.
- Targeting – This is how you determine who will see your ads. Specifically, modern advertisers use a wealth of behavioural and demographic data to target online ads.
Perhaps you can already see how we’ve discussed ethics in digital marketing apply here. From a legal point of view, you need to ensure that you have the right to use any data or intellectual property in your display ads.
However, regulatory issues in online advertising are somewhat underdeveloped. Unlike traditional advertising, the exact law about what you can or can’t say in an online ad is often unclear. Generally, the final word comes from social media platforms rather than governments.
Online ads also create a host of new problems for the ethics and legalities of digital marketing. In some, data-driven ad targeting can even be too effective. Since social media users see ads based on their interests, advertising can often reinforce their views and create echo chambers. This is an ethical issue in political advertising, as users will only ever hear one side of the story.
Ethics and Legalities of Digital Marketing in Summary
Digital marketing, like any other form of marketing, operates under a set of rules and guidelines to ensure effective adherence to the ethics and legalities of digital marketing. Here’s a summary of key rules you should follow:
- Compliance with Laws and Regulations:
- Adhere to all applicable laws and regulations, including data protection laws, consumer protection laws, and advertising standards.
- Transparency:
- Be transparent with your audience about who you are, what you’re promoting, and any affiliations or sponsorships.
- Consent and Privacy:
- Obtain consent before collecting or using personal information and respect user privacy.
- Truthfulness and Accuracy:
- Ensure all marketing messages and content are truthful, accurate, and not misleading.
- Quality and Value:
- Provide quality content and real value to your audience.
- Targeting and Personalization:
- Use targeting and personalization responsibly to provide relevant content without infringing on privacy.
- Accessibility:
- Ensure digital marketing materials are accessible to individuals with disabilities.
- Sustainability:
- Consider the environmental impact of digital marketing activities and strive for sustainability.
- Ethical Practices:
- Uphold ethical practices in all digital marketing activities, including respecting cultural sensitivities and promoting diversity and inclusivity.
- Continuous Learning:
- Stay updated with the latest trends, technologies, and best practices in digital marketing.
- Customer Engagement:
- Engage with your audience in a meaningful and respectful manner.
By following these rules, digital marketers can create campaigns that not only achieve their business goals but also build trust with their audience, comply with legal standards, and contribute positively to the broader digital ecosystem.
Legalities of Digital Marketing Around the World
It’s no secret that governments have a hard time regulating social networks. This can make the ethics and legalities of digital marketing hard to pin down. There are two reasons why the law struggles to deal with social media:
- Social networking sites have a new business model. Regulators don’t know how to treat them based on existing categories of businesses. Are they publishers, utilities or technology companies?
- Social media companies are incredibly powerful. Google’s annual revenues are over $160 billion. This is higher than the annual GDP of some European countries.
Because of this, the law can’t always keep pace with new ethical constraints in marketing.
As such, complying with legal and regulatory issues is the bare minimum you should do. Indeed, ethical issues can have just as large an impact on your business’s bottom line due to reputational damage. As such, working with an ethical digital marketing agency to establish responsible practices is vital.
So next time you are reviewing your brand strategy, updating your adherence to copyright laws, or reviewing how you are using social media platforms, such as Reddit, ensure you consider the ethics and legalities of digital marketing.
The Growing Importance of Ethics in Digital Marketing
Recent surveys reveal increasing consumer concerns about ethics in digital marketing – 91% express worry about how brands use their data, while 85% want complete transparency.
With digital ad spending projected to grow to $526 billion by 2023 (Forrester), marketers must prioritize ethical practices to build trust. Studies show that 77% of people will stop buying from brands that violate ethics.
Key Digital Marketing Laws and Regulations
- CAN-SPAM Act – Sets rules for commercial emails, opt-out requirements, and sender ID—fines up to $41,484 per violation.
- COPPA – Protects children’s privacy for sites/apps targeting users under 13. Enforced by FTC with fines up to $43,792 per violation.
- GDPR – European data protection regulations. Restricts data collection, storage and use without explicit consent. Fines up to €20 million or 4% of global revenue.
- FTC Truth in Advertising – Guidelines prohibit deceptive, misleading marketing. All claims must be substantiated. Violations mean legal action.
Ethical Content Marketing Practices
- Clearly disclose sponsored and affiliated content; don’t misrepresent.
- Ensure transparency about free products/perks received in exchange for content.
- Avoid overly promotional language disguised as organic recommendations.
- Respect copyright, properly attribute sources, and obtain usage rights for references.
- Ensure accessibility features through alt text, captions, and site navigation.
Email Marketing Ethics
- Honour opt-outs quickly make unsubscribing easy.
- Obtain double opt-in consent before sending emails.
- Ensure subject lines and preheaders are transparent about intent.
- Don’t purchase lists or send emails without permission.
Building an Ethical Digital Marketing Strategy
- Audit practices to identify potential issues.
- Comply fully with regulations and platform guidelines.
- Install safeguards to protect consumer privacy and data.
- Transparent communication and consent processes.
- Check trademarks and intellectual property usage.
- Accessibility for target audiences.
- Disclosures for sponsored and affiliate content.
- Regular ethics training for teams.
Staying up-to-date on guidelines and putting consumers first with an ethical approach ensures digital marketing success while building brand trust.
Resources:
- IAB Guide to Ethical Digital Marketing
- DMA Code of Ethics – https://thedma.org/accountability/ethics-and-compliance/dma-code-of-ethics/
Frequently Asked Questions on Legalities in Digital Marketing
Q: What disclosures are required for affiliated links or sponsored content?
Use clear disclosures like “Paid Ad”, “Sponsored”, and “Affiliate Link” when promoting affiliate offers or sponsored content. FTC guidelines require transparent disclosure to avoid misleading users.
Q: Can I email purchased lists or prospects who didn’t opt in?
No, the CAN-SPAM Act explicitly prohibits sending unsolicited emails without consent. All email lists must originate from opt-ins to avoid illegal spamming.
Q: How can I ensure my ads and content comply with FTC truth in advertising laws?
All claims and testimonials must be validated, substantiated and not misleading. Disclose paid vs organic, be transparent about results, and provide evidence for any stated benefits.
Q: What precautions should I take when running contests and giveaways?
Read all platform contest rules, clearly disclose terms/eligibility, follow local laws on prizes and taxes, and obtain consent to use winner details in the promotion.
Q: How do I respect copyrights and avoid infringement on my content?
Avoid copying chunks of text directly from other sites. Properly attribute statistics, quotes and references. Use only legally acquired images and videos or stock media with rights.
ProfileTree
Claire Mulligan // 5th May 2024 
Eman Sameh // 26th July 2024